Tax guide

Is crypto trading income? Capital or revenue for SARS

Published: 14 November 2026Written by Coinfig team

Crypto profits in South Africa are taxed in one of two ways. If you hold crypto as an investment, a profit on disposal is a capital gain, and only 40% of it (after the annual exclusion) is added to your taxable income. If you trade crypto, or bought it to sell at a profit, the profit is ordinary income and all of it is taxed at your marginal rate of up to 45%. SARS says which one applies is tested under existing case law. There is no crypto-specific rule and no holding period that decides it for you.

This guide covers that test: what SARS looks at, how the courts have framed it, what changes if your crypto is on revenue account, and the records that let you support your position. If you already know you're an investor, the calculation is in capital gains tax on crypto in South Africa. The overall picture is in the complete guide to crypto tax in South Africa. If you'd rather work through the questions one at a time, the help centre has a capital or revenue flowchart.

Much of what follows comes from section 3.2.4 of the SARS draft guide to the taxation of crypto assets of 1 July 2026. It's draft guidance for public comment and does not create a practice generally prevailing, but the court cases it quotes are settled law.

Why the label matters so much

Take an R80,000 profit in the 2027 tax year, and assume your marginal rate is 31% all the way through. This is an illustrative calculation, and it assumes the profit is your only capital gain for the year.

Capital account Revenue account
Profit R80,000 R80,000
Annual exclusion (R50,000) None
Inclusion 40% of R30,000 = R12,000 All R80,000
Tax at 31% R3,720 R24,800

Same money, more than six times the tax. That gap is why SARS looks closely at the label, and why you can't simply pick the cheaper one. The draft guide (3.2.4) points out that under section 102 of the Tax Administration Act the onus of proving whether an amount is capital or revenue rests on you, the taxpayer.

Intention is the starting point

The central question is why you acquired and held the crypto. Selling in the course of a business, or as part of a scheme of profit-making, points to revenue. Realising a capital asset "to best advantage" points to capital. The draft guide stresses that you look at your intention at three moments: when you bought, while you held, and when you sold, because intention can change.

The Supreme Court of Appeal summarised the current position in CSARS v Capstone 556, which the draft guide quotes. Your stated intention is only one factor. The court also looks at the nature of your business activities, how long you held the asset and how long you expected to hold it when you bought it, and the kind of risk you took on. Where there was no clear intention at the outset, the court said it is better to accept that than to invent one.

The courts have been clear that saying "I'm an investor" isn't enough. The draft guide calls your own statement of intention your ipse dixit (Latin for "he himself said it") and says it is not decisive without objective support from the facts.

The factors SARS weighs

You may see these called "badges of trade", a term borrowed from UK practice. SARS's draft guide doesn't use it, but its list does the same job. None of the factors decides a case alone.

  • What you said and why. Your reasons for buying and selling, tested against what you actually did.
  • Your conduct with that asset. Research, monitoring and how you managed the holding.
  • Your business and occupation. A trade connected to your day job looks different from a side investment.
  • Frequency. Many similar transactions point to revenue.
  • Holding period, both actual and expected at purchase. Longer leans capital, but it isn't conclusive.
  • Return on the investment. Crypto usually pays no income stream, so profit on sale is the only return. The draft guide compares this with Krugerrands and notes that courts have found both capital and revenue on gold coins held for long periods.
  • Risk. Crypto sits at the volatile end of asset classes. Someone saving for retirement would usually pick safer options, so a high-risk choice can say something about purpose, though diversification can justify some exposure.

The draft guide also gives two pointers specific to crypto. An investor who regularly rebalances a crypto portfolio to keep up with market moves is likely to be regarded as trading on revenue account. And crypto held in wallets built for very fast transactions, such as on the Lightning network, is typically subject to high-frequency use, which often indicates revenue.

There is no three-year rule for crypto

Section 9C deems gains on equity shares held for at least three years to be capital. People often assume crypto works the same way. It doesn't. The draft guide (3.2.4) says section 9C applies only to equity shares and participatory interests in collective investment schemes, and that crypto is not subject to it. It gives an example: a trader who sells a coin five years after buying it still has a revenue profit, because the coin was bought to be traded.

What the SARS examples show

The draft guide's worked examples are useful because they show where SARS draws lines.

A frequent part-time trader (Example 3). A full-time bank employee researches crypto most evenings and makes 200 disposals across 10 assets in year one and 800 across 30 in year two, to build retirement savings. Revenue, despite the long-term goal, because the plan was to reach it by trading at a profit.

A five-year education fund (Example 4). Parents buy three types of crypto, about two purchases a year, planning to sell after five years to pay university fees. Revenue. Holding for five years didn't change the fact that the crypto was bought to be sold at a profit for a known purpose.

An inheritance (Example 5). Someone inherits Solana, has never traded, and sells it the next year to buy a car. Capital. They didn't buy it to sell at a profit, and nothing they did afterwards suggested a change of intention.

Arbitrage (section 4.6). Buying on one exchange and selling on another to capture a price difference is inherently profit-driven. The draft guide says all actions by an arbitrage trader are on revenue account.

When your intention changes or is mixed

Intention can shift, but the draft guide notes that more than a mere decision to sell is needed to turn a capital asset into trading stock. The courts describe it as crossing the Rubicon into a business of selling. A change has tax effects straight away, not only when you sell. Moving from trading stock to capital triggers income equal to market value, with a CGT base cost at that value. Moving from capital to trading stock is a deemed CGT disposal at market value, with the trading stock starting at that value.

Where you have more than one intention, courts look for the dominant one. A secondary purpose of making a profit is enough for revenue, as in CIR v Tod, which the draft guide discusses.

How revenue treatment works

If your crypto is trading stock, the sale price is gross income and the cost of the crypto is deductible under section 11(a). At the end of the tax year, crypto you still hold is closing stock under section 22. Because crypto is a financial instrument, the draft guide (3.2.5) says closing stock must be at cost price, not at a written-down value, even if the market has fallen. The Act doesn't prescribe a stock method, but section 22(5) prohibits LIFO.

There's no annual exclusion and no inclusion rate. The full net profit goes into taxable income, and expenses incurred in producing that income may be deductible. A trading loss is treated very differently from a capital loss, and from the 2027 tax year the threshold for ring-fencing trading losses under section 20A drops sharply. That's covered in crypto losses and tax in South Africa.

Crypto you earn, such as mining and staking rewards, is a separate question. It's income when you receive it whichever way you hold your other coins. See staking and mining income.

Questions to settle before the figures are final

For an accountant preparing a client's return, or for you preparing your own, three questions are worth answering before the figures are final:

  • What was the intention, and does the actual activity support the treatment you're applying?
  • Have all exchanges and wallets been included, including closed ones, and are unexplained movements investigated?
  • Can every acquisition cost be traced to a record?

Evidence that supports your position

Because the onus is on you, keep records made at the time, not reasons written years later. Useful evidence includes notes on why you bought, your full transaction history from every exchange and wallet, holding periods per asset, how often you trade, and whether you use bots, leverage or margin. The draft guide (6.3) says records must generally be kept for at least five years from the date you submit the return. Crypto tax records SARS expects you to keep has the full retention rules.

Coinfig lets you set capital or revenue treatment and shows it as an assumption in your report, so your practitioner can see what was applied. It doesn't decide the question for you. If your case is borderline, that is a judgement for a registered tax practitioner.

Frequently asked questions

How many trades make me a crypto trader?

There's no number. SARS looks at all the facts. Frequency is one factor, alongside intention, holding period, risk and how organised the activity is. In the draft guide's Example 4, about two purchases a year were still revenue because of the purpose.

If I hold crypto for more than three years, is the gain capital?

No. The three-year rule in section 9C covers equity shares and some collective investment schemes only. The SARS draft guide says crypto is not subject to it.

Can I treat some crypto as capital and some as revenue?

Yes, the test applies to each asset and its facts. A long-term Bitcoin holding and an active altcoin trading account can be treated differently, as long as your records support each.

Sources


This article is general information, not tax advice. Crypto tax outcomes depend on your specific circumstances. For complex situations, consult a qualified tax practitioner.

Turn your exchange history into the figures for your return

Connect via read-only API or upload CSVs, run the completeness check, and export your report.

Get started on Coinfig